Insurance News & Views: California Auto Insurance: The Regulatory Battle Continues

Bookmark and Share
January 28th, 2010 | Tags:

Posted by the publisher at Insurance News & Views

California is the largest state in the union, and also the largest auto insurance market (as the Los Angeles traffic jams remind us.)  Due to a quirky blend of left-of-center politics combined with a “public ballot” provision in its laws, controversial and politically-charged issues often end up being decided in a direct vote during election time.

A challenge to Proposition 103 is in the works

In 1988, a landmark public ballot changed the auto insurance industry.  It was (and still is) called Proposition 103, and it spells out in very specific terms how auto insurance companies are allowed to set prices.  Although this system isn’t nearly as strict as Massachusetts or North Carolina used to be, auto insurers have very little wiggle room.  In response, Progressive Insurance (which prides itself on being able to use every speck of information to set prices) almost completely abandoned the state. They have since slowly returned.

First of all, the law spells out very clearly the only four criteria allowed to determine auto insurance rates:
1. Driving record
2. Miles driven (which is usually self-declared and almost impossible to verify, although the nerds at Progressive are working hard on this issue.)
3. Driving experience
4. Any other factor that “can be shown scientifically to have a substantial relationship to the risk of loss.” These factors must be explicitly approved by the Insurance Commissioner.

Among the many factors that cannot be used (even though they are highly predictive of future claims) are ZIP code, credit score, marital status, type of job and income.  Another factor – which has become a large bone of contention and is the subject of this article – is what is known as “continuous coverage.”  Many people either lose or drop auto insurance coverage for “good” or “bad” reasons.  They have their insurance canceled due to a DWI, or stop paying their insurance due to a lack of money.  They may also move out of the country on a job assignment (or a military deployment.)  For whatever reason, a lack of continuous coverage is predictive of higher claims.

Of course, continuous coverage is not one of the “big three” provisions of Prop 103, and is on shaky ground qualifying for criteria number four.  So, an organization known as Californians for Fair Auto Insurance Rates (CalFAIR for short) successfully got the required signatures to put the Continuous Coverage Auto Insurance Discount Act on the June 8, 2010 ballot.  Note the careful wording – it isn’t a rate “increase” for lack of continuous coverage, its a “discount” for continuous coverage!

Harvey Rosenfield vs. George Joseph (again)

Of course, consumer groups have hit the roof over this, and are campaigning hard to block the “surcharge.” One group, called Consumer Watchdog, was founded by the original author of Proposition 103, Harvey Rosenfield.  Why is Consumer Watchdog so enraged by this initiative?  The company that provides a lot of funding to CalFAIR is none other than Mercury General, the third largest auto insurer in California and bitter enemy of Harvey Rosenfield.

Mercury General was founded by George Joseph in 1961, and pioneered a lot of the modern underwriting and pricing techniques that are now commonplace in the auto insurance industry.  Mr. Joseph worked very hard to keep the rules loose, so that (in his view) different drivers got the price that they deserved.  In Mercury General’s point of view, less risky drivers subsidize high-risk drivers if you leave out crucial information – even if it has a tenuous relationship with driving record (e.g., ZIP code, credit scoring.)

Is it a discount, or a surcharge?

This continuous coverage issue creates an interesting thought experiment.  When is the lack of a discount a surcharge?  Where do you “draw the line?”  In June, California voters will decide.