Author Archive

SF Chronicle recommends: No on Proposition 17

April 18th, 2010

Special interests go directly to voters – Chronicle recommends: No on Proposition 17

EDITORIAL, THE SAN FRANCISCO CHRONICLE

The Mercury Insurance Group is promoting a ballot measure that would allow it to offer discounts to the vast majority of California drivers.

What’s wrong with this picture?

Plenty, on closer inspection.

Proposition 17 might provide a slight price break to Californians when they switch insurers. Mercury has projected that it could cut premiums to new customers by about 5 percent. But there is no free lunch. One customer’s discount is another’s surcharge. Critics warn that a discount offered to the 80 percent of Californians who carry insurance would result in substantially higher rates for drivers who were not previously insured – even if it was because they did not own a car, had a brief lapse in coverage or were attending college or serving in the military and were thus away from home for an extended time. The measure offers protection for troops stationed overseas – but not for those on stateside stints.

This measure would represent the first major revision of Proposition 103, a 1988 measure designed to make auto insurance more affordable and readily available to Californians.

Under Prop. 103, premiums must be approved by the Department of Insurance and companies must show a connection between price and risk. There are three primary factors:

– Driving record, including accidents and moving violations.

– Miles driven.

– Years of driving experience.

Insurers also are allowed to submit evidence of enhanced or reduced risk on a limited menu of other variables in their rate-setting requests. For example, some companies provide discounts for vehicles with air bags or anti-lock brakes, or factor a driver’s age or marital status in the premium. Companies are allowed to provide discounts to their long-term customers – and many do. But they are not allowed to discriminate against new customers who are not insured.

There are sound policy reasons for this prohibition. Affordability is one of the main reasons drivers lack insurance. Surcharges on the previously uninsured would only increase the barrier for those who want coverage but cannot afford it.

Also, insurers have shown a quantifiable link between price and risk to justify the discounts to their long-term customers. Drivers who stay with the same company tend to have had fewer claims.

Mercury representatives claim that, if Prop. 17 passes, they could show a similar correlation to justify discounts to customers they lure from other companies. But the key word is claim. We asked for evidence to support their argument that the continually insured – with the same driving record, same annual miles, same years of experience – posed a lower risk. They could not.

Auto insurance is highly competitive, and rates vary widely. A married couple with a clean driving record might pay anywhere between $2,000 and nearly $6,000 for standard coverage, under a sampling we entered on the Department of Insurance Web site www.insurance.ca.gov. It’s apparent that many Californians are staying with their insurance companies because they are not shopping around for price – or perhaps because they are satisfied with their carrier. Incidentally, Mercury scored low marks in the 2009 J.D. Power survey of customer satisfaction.

The Prop. 17 formula is likely to produce, at best, a marginal benefit to Californians shopping for a new company – and a daunting additional cost for those who are desperate to get coverage.

Two California companies are spending millions of dollars on June initiatives that each believes will give it a competitive advantage. This is not what Gov. Hiram Johnson and other reformers had in mind a century ago when they established direct democracy as a tool for the citizenry to bypass a Legislature that had become captive to special interests, notably the Southern Pacific Railroad. Both propositions should be rejected.

California Democratic Party Opposes Prop 17 – The Mercury Insurance Ripoff

April 18th, 2010

NEWS RELEASE:
Contact: Doug Heller 310-480-4170

Los Angeles, CA – The California Democratic Party voted today to oppose Prop 17 on the June ballot.  Prop 17 would allow car insurance companies to increase premiums for millions of California drivers based on their history of purchasing auto insurance.  At its weekend convention in Los Angeles, the Democratic Party joined consumer, labor, senior and veterans groups fighting the deceptive ballot measure funded by Mercury Insurance, California’s third largest auto insurer.  To date, Mercury has spent $5.25 million on its Prop 17 campaign.

“The Democratic Party voted to stand with consumers against a self-serving insurance company that is trying to buy an election so it can charge drivers higher premiums,” said consumer advocate Doug Heller with the Stop Prop 17 campaign.  ”Opposing Prop 17 is a no-brainer for anyone who allies themselves with average Californians ahead of insurance companies.”

Prop 17 would create an insurance surcharge on drivers, including soldiers and seniors, who have had a lapse in car insurance coverage for virtually any reason during the past five years, or who missed a single payment. Under the measure, people who stopped driving and didn’t need insurance for a time would be required to pay up to a thousand dollars more for car insurance when they sought to restart coverage. Currently, insurance companies are prohibited from imposing such a surcharge in California.

Other opponents of Prop 17 include: Consumers Union, the publisher of Consumer Reports magazine, VoteVets.org, California Nurses Association, California Federation of Teachers, California Labor Federation, Consumer Watchdog, Consumer Federation of California, and the California Alliance of Retired Americans.

Last week, Insurance Commissioner Steve Poizner announced an administrative lawsuit against Prop 17 sponsor Mercury Insurance in response to findings of widespread overcharges and illegal discrimination by the company.  Mercury’s reputation for cheating policyholders is also reflected in the company’s consistently low J.D. Power customer satisfaction ranking.  Read more about the Insurance Commissioner’s Mercury investigation and lawsuit at: http://bit.ly/akp7aJ .

- 30 -

For more information, please visit:  / or find us on twitter at:  http://twitter.com/stopmercury and facebook at:  http://www.facebook.com/stopprop17

LA Daily News: No on Prop. 17

April 17th, 2010

Message might be good, but the messenger is untrustworthy

EDITORIAL, THE LOS ANGELES DAILY NEWS

Californians will likely have trouble figuring out how to vote on Proposition 17, the auto insurance measure.

On the one hand, enabling a more competitive insurance marketplace benefits good consumers who too often are forced to subsidize the reckless ways of bad and irresponsible drivers.

Proposition 17 would allow insurance companies to lure customers away from competitors offering a discount for having continuous coverage for the past five years. Right now, the law allows an insurance company to offer that discount only to existing customers after the first policy period, usually six months.

Competition is good for consumers. But there are worrisome aspects to this proposition that ought to give voters pause. For one thing, the discounts for some would be balanced on the backs of drivers who haven’t maintained auto insurance consistently for the past three years for whatever reason – a temporary disability, long-term illness, school or training, extended time out of the country, job loss, etc.

The lapse might have nothing to do with their driving ability, experience on the road or the number of miles they commute – the three factors that the law allows for the calculation of individual insurance rates.

Customers generally would be eligible for the discounts if their coverage had not lapsed for more than 90 days in the past five years. If the lapse occurred because of military service abroad, the discount would still be available.

But the most troubling thing about this initiative is that the Proposition 17 campaign is funded almost entirely by Mercury Insurance, which also happens to be the fourth-largest insurer in California.

This is a special-interest initiative, pure and simple.

Company officials admit that business is good, but this would make it better. That seems like a questionable reason to tinker with one of the state’s most important consumer safeguards.

It strains credibility to believe that a profit-making company such as Mercury Insurance Co. would spend $3.5 million to qualify and support an initiative simply to benefit consumers. That the cause has not been embraced by other insurance companies makes it all the more suspect.

Mercury was accused of overcharging and illegal practices years ago by the California Department of Insurance. Last Monday, Insurance Commissioner Steve Poizner, who is running for the Republican gubernatorial nomination, announced that Mercury had continued the practices and may face fines for making unfair and excess charges in homeowner and auto policies. This is not a company that instills trust in its claims that the measure would only benefit consumers and not result in surcharges for some motorists.

Voters should be aware that drivers in states that do allow surcharges like the ones Mercury seeks often pay much higher premiums. The surcharges could be so steep that drivers would be unable to afford coverage and would join the large number of uninsured motorists on California’s roads. Mercury claims it would not impose surcharges on drivers with a lapse in their coverage record, and even claims it could not do so.

But the analysis by the Legislative Analyst that will appear on the ballot makes it clear that Mercury, or any other insurer, could indeed impose surcharges under Proposition 17.

With the passage of Proposition 103 in 1988, voters tried to level the field in insurance rates and get rid of gimmicks and strategies that unwittingly cost customers. Insurance companies understandably disliked the new laws that restricted how they figured rates, but it hasn’t stopped California from being one of the most competitive insurance rates in the country.

Proposition 17 is an attempt to bypass the Proposition 103 rules by creating a new way to charge some people less and others more. In California, one person’s discount is another one’s surcharge.

Fair competition may be good for consumers, but self-serving and suspect special interest initiatives are not. Vote no on Proposition 17.

CA-Gov Brown Calls For Specific Debates, Will Not Issue Specific Positions

April 17th, 2010

By David Dayen, FIREDOGLAKE.COM

Jerry Brown tried to shake up the California Governor’s race by demanding debates with all the major candidates today, but at the same time responded to criticism for not being specific enough on the major issues facing California by talking about federal issues not under the gubernatorial purview and declining to give a position on the upcoming June ballot measures.

“I am not prepared to issue positions” on ballot measures like Prop. 17, the Mercury Insurance measure that would allow auto insurers to jack up rates for individuals if there is a lapse in their coverage, said Brown, the former Governor and current Attorney General, at a post-speech press conference. When asked again about specifically what he would do to bring jobs to the state, he cited getting banks to lend to small businesses. When told that was a federal issue, Brown said “I am a citizen of the Republic.” Pressed further, Brown said that he wold not favor new taxes unless people “want them and vote for them,” which he said was a “tough thing to say in front of this crowd.” He actually didn’t say it in his speech. He also proposed moving authority on local spending issues back to local control, decentralizing the state budget structure to a degree.

Brown said that people aren’t paying attention to the race and that “we will be more than competitive” on television in the fall. He suggested that people “will have all the information they need” to make their decision in November, and that “people will recoil from all the information” that they’ll have, an allusion to Meg Whitman’s prodigious spending. When asked why then he would call for more information through debates, Brown said they would be more substantive and of interest.

Brown didn’t seem terribly hopeful that Whitman or Poizner would actually accept the challenge. Asked if it was more likely that Whitman would release her tax return or agree to the debate, Brown said, “It’s a close question.” However, he added, “I wouldn’t have made the challenge if I didn’t entertain the possibility that they’d accept it,” and hoped it would “rise to the ministerial level” of negotiations between all the campaigns. “The Sherpas will meet next week.”

Certainly, the gubernatorial campaign won’t be dull.

No word on whether Peter Schurman, the former executive director of MoveOn.org who is running to the left of Brown in the Democratic primary on a platform of single payer health care and changing the 2/3 requirement for budget and taxes, would be allowed to participate in these debates. I’m guessing no.

CA Labor Federation Votes to Oppose Insurance-Funded Prop 17 on June Ballot

April 15th, 2010

Consumer Advocates Urge CA Democratic Party to Oppose Prop 17 at This Weekend’s State Convention

CONTACT: Naomi Seligman, 310-392-0522, ext. 318; or Doug Heller, ext. 309

Santa Monica, CA –  This week, the California Labor Federation joined a growing list of organizations in opposition to Proposition 17, the Mercury Insurance-sponsored measure that would allow insurance companies to raise drivers’ premiums based on their history of buying auto insurance.

Prop 17 is also opposed by consumer and citizen groups including Consumers Union, Consumer Watchdog, Consumer Federation of California, California Alliance of Retired Americans and VoteVets.org.  Click here to see the full list of Stop Prop 17 coalition partners.

The California Labor Federation is made up of more than 1,200 AFL-CIO and Change to Win unions, representing 2.1 million union members in manufacturing, retail, construction, hospitality, public sector, health care, entertainment and other industries.

Doug Heller, with the Stop Prop 17 campaign, said today, “Labor organizations that represent millions of California’s working families have joined the fight to stop this insurance industry ripoff that will increase the price of auto insurance. While Mercury Insurance will spend millions of dollars to try and buy this election, groups representing millions of Californians will be warning voters to oppose Prop 17.”

This weekend the Democratic Party of California, at its convention, will decide whether to oppose Prop 17. Party delegates are being urged to join labor, consumer, senior and veterans groups and oppose this insurance company funded initiative.

Earlier this week, the California Department of Insurance issued a scathing report about Prop 17 sponsor Mercury Insurance’s history of overcharging and discriminating against customers and the company’s failure to make promised changes after similar investigations in 1998 and 2002. The Department has filed an administrative lawsuit against Mercury.

“Democratic party members should take a strong stand against an industry bully with a nasty track record of cheating Calfiornia drivers that is now running a deceptive campaign in order to raise auto insurance premiums on Californians already struggling in a tough economy,” said Heller.

Prop 17 would create an insurance surcharge on drivers, including soldiers and seniors, who have had a lapse in car insurance coverage for virtually any reason during the past five years, or who missed a single payment. Under the measure, people who stopped driving and didn’t need insurance for a time would be required to pay up to a thousand dollars more for car insurance when they sought to restart coverage. Currently, insurance companies are prohibited from imposing such a surcharge in California.

Mercury Insurance has spent over $5.25 million on its campaign for Prop 17 to date.

- 30 -

NEW! Prop 17 Sponsor, Mercury Insurance’s Deceptive Practices Exposed

April 14th, 2010

Prop 17 Sponsor, Mercury Insurance's Deceptive Practices Exposed

April 14th, 2010

Marketing to Distrust

April 14th, 2010

By Anne Landman, PR Watch.org

Enron, Goldman Sachs, Halliburton, Monsanto, Blackwater, Bank of America, Citigroup, Cigna, Aetna, Enron, Arthur Andersen, Mercury Insurance, Philip Morris… These are just a few corporate names that engender feelings of distrust, anger and betrayal. They represent scandals, greed, blatant disregard for public welfare, lavish spending of taxpayer money and other negatives, and serve as reminders about how corporate wrongdoing has brought shame on our country and harmed millions.

But as the public grows more distrustful of big corporations, corporations are fighting back by evolving more clever and sophisticated forms of public relations. Their goal? To manipulate public attitudes and assure that widespread negative feelings don’t block their ability to do business. Increasingly, corporations are engaging in variations on the theme of “corporate social responsibility,” to try and persuade us that they can be trusted again.

Steve Poizner Goes After Mercury Insurance For Possible Overcharges

April 13th, 2010

By Dennis Romero, LAWEEKLY.COM

California Insurance Commissioner Steve Poizner announced this week that Mercury Insurance “may have illegally overcharged thousands of Californians for auto and homeowners insurance,” according to a statement from his office.

An “examination” of the company found that it was sometimes raising rates on drivers who had accidents, even though the collisions weren’t their fault, and that it was excluding some bartenders, liquor store owners, painters, cocktail waitress and waiters and artists from coverage.

Mercury was quick to point out, however, that Poizner is seeking the Republican nomination for California governor. The company stated that “political interests” were at play in Monday afternoon’s big announcement.

Even Poizner’s own spokesman acknowledged that making such a big announcement about such violations was unusual. But Poizner’s office argues that the company has repeated violations it had previously agreed to fix.

Mercury is the $3.5 million main backer of Prop. 17, a November ballot initiative that would allow transferable “loyalty discounts” for drivers who change carriers. But the rates would not apply to those who let their insurance lapse, therefore becoming a clever way to raise rates on some drivers, critics say.

Poizner’s office stated that Mercury could face $5,000 fines for each violation it found.

Did Mercury Insurance Scam Its California Customers?

April 13th, 2010

By Zach Berens, LAIST.COM

As the insurance behemoth bankrolls Prop 17 on the June ballot, the company is finding their way into the news by another another route.

“An examination done by the Department of Insurance appears to show that Mercury Insurance has disregarded California’s consumer protection statutes and overcharged consumers,” Insurance Commissioner Steve Poizner said yesterday. “In addition, the Department’s examination finds that Mercury Insurance has apparently continued to violate the law despite agreements with the state to terminate its illegal behavior.”

Various allegation are being thrown at the company, including barring bartenders, liqour store owners, painters, cocktail waitresses, waiters and artists. The company also still hasn’t corrected violations made in 1998 and 2002, according to Poizner. Ouch.