Mercury representatives claim that, if Prop. 17 passes, they could show a similar correlation to justify discounts to customers they lure from other companies. But the key word is claim. We asked for evidence to support their argument that the continually insured – with the same driving record, same annual miles, same years of experience – posed a lower risk. They could not.
Read more...In the News
LA Daily News: No on Prop. 17
Message might be good, but the messenger is untrustworthy
EDITORIAL, THE LOS ANGELES DAILY NEWS
Californians will likely have trouble figuring out how to vote on Proposition 17, the auto insurance measure.
On the one hand, enabling a more competitive…
CA-Gov Brown Calls For Specific Debates, Will Not Issue Specific Positions
“I am not prepared to issue positions” on ballot measures like Prop. 17, the Mercury Insurance measure that would allow auto insurers to jack up rates for individuals if there is a lapse in their coverage, said Brown, the former Governor and current Attorney General, at a post-speech press conference.
Read more...Marketing to Distrust
Enron, Goldman Sachs, Halliburton, Monsanto, Blackwater, Bank of America, Citigroup, Cigna, Aetna, Enron, Arthur Andersen, Mercury Insurance, Philip Morris… These are just a few corporate names that engender feelings of distrust, anger and betrayal.
Read more...Steve Poizner Goes After Mercury Insurance For Possible Overcharges
California Insurance Commissioner Steve Poizner announced this week that Mercury Insurance “may have illegally overcharged thousands of Californians for auto and homeowners insurance,” according to a statement from his office. An “examination” of the company found that it was sometimes raising rates on drivers who had accidents, even though the collisions weren’t their fault, and that it was excluding some bartenders, liquor store owners, painters, cocktail waitress and waiters and artists from coverage.
Read more...Did Mercury Insurance Scam Its California Customers?
“An examination done by the Department of Insurance appears to show that Mercury Insurance has disregarded California’s consumer protection statutes and overcharged consumers,” Insurance Commissioner Steve Poizner said yesterday. “In addition, the Department’s examination finds that Mercury Insurance has apparently continued to violate the law despite agreements with the state to terminate its illegal behavior.”
Read more...California Accuses Insurer Mercury Of Overcharging Customers
The proposition’s leading critic, prominent consumer advocate Harvey Rosenfield, said the charges are further evidence of Mercury’s anti-consumer orientation. “This ought to put the nail in the coffin for Prop. 17 for any voters paying attention,” Rosenfield said.
Read more...Insurer May Face Fines For Overcharging
“This troubling report shows Mercury has overcharged its customers for a decade and a half but wants us to believe Proposition 17 will lower premiums,” said Harvey Rosenfield, who spearheaded the landmark insurance reforms under Proposition 103, some provisions of which would be repealed if Proposition 17 passes. “That’s like Bernie Madoff backing a ballot measure to protect investors.”
Read more...Mercury Insurance May Face Millions In Fines
Consumer advocates including Harvey Rosenfield, founder of Consumer Watchdog of Santa Monica, oppose Prop. 17, arguing that the measure will raise insurance rates for some Californians and allow the firm to legalize discriminatory practices and price increases that are currently barred by Prop. 103, the landmark insurance reform law approved by state voters in 1988. Rosenfield, reacting to the new state report, called on California regulators to lift Mercury’s license to do business in California – saying he has never seen “such a brazen and widespread series of violations” in an industry that he has monitored for decades.
Read more...New State Report Alleges Repeat Violations and Discrimination By Mercury Insurance, Prop. 17 Backer
Mercury Insurance Group, the high-profile firm that has put up $3.5 million to back a ballot measure that consumer advocates say would raise insurance rates for some Californians, continues to violate state laws, has engaged in discriminatory practices and may have illegally overcharged thousands of consumers, according to a new report from the state Department of Insurance to be released today.
Read more...