NEWS RELEASE
CONTACT: Harvey Rosenfield, 310-345-8816; or Naomi Seligman, 310-526-0747
Insurance Companies Spending Millions On Prop 17, $735K on SD Senate Race
San Diego, CA — Long-time insurance reformer Harvey Rosenfield is in San Diego today, traveling with a red emergency beacon, to warn voters to be aware of what the insurance industry is trying to get away with on the ballot this June. Rosenfield will highlight the $10 million spent by Mercury Insurance to pass the auto insurance rate hike initiative Prop 17 and more than $735,000 spent by insurance companies and associated political committees in the Democratic primary to replace San Diego State Senator Denise Ducheny.
The insurance company campaign for Prop 17 has become a David versus Goliath battle over whether or not insurance companies should be given new power to raise premiums on drivers. The sponsor of 17, Mercury Insurance, is blanketing the television and radio airwaves with deceptive ads through election day. Consumer groups fighting 17 have a small budget and a limited ability to buy expensive television commercials.
“You’ve got an insurance company that has already spent $10 million and could spend another $10 million,” said Harvey Rosenfield with the Campaign for Consumer Rights, which is sponsoring the effort to stop Prop 17. “They’ve been carpet-bombing the state with ads. We’re just throwing a rock back with a sling shot.”
The opponents point out that despite the insurance company’s massive financial advantage, nearly every newspaper in California has weighed in against Prop 17 as well as all the state’s consumer protection groups such as Consumers Union, the nonprofit publisher of Consumer Reports. If enacted, Prop 17 would allow car insurance companies to increase premiums for drivers based on their history of purchasing auto insurance. Such a surcharge has been illegal in California for more than 20 years.
Insurance industry trying to buy San Diego senate seat, too
Rosenfield noted that Prop 17 isn’t the only insurance-sponsored effort on the ballot. The industry is aggressively campaigning for insurance executive Juan Vargas (a former Assemblyman) in the race for California’s southern-most Senate seat. Vargas helped shepherd a legislative version of Prop 17 through the Assembly when he has chairman of the Insurance Committee in 2003.
Property and casualty insurance companies and the Civil Justice Association have waged a massive campaign to elect Vargas and defeat his competitor Assemblywoman Mary Salas. The Civil Justice Association, whose board of directors has substantially more insurance representation than any other industry, has spent $613,333 in independent expenditures in support of Vargas as well as $61,963 against Salas. Additionally, Vargas has received more than $60,000 from auto, home, medical malpractice and other insurers, including $2,000 from Prop 17 sponsor Mercury. Salas has received about $4,000 from similar sources.
- 30 -
For more information, please visit: / or find us on twitter at: http://twitter.com/stopmercury and facebook at: http://www.facebook.com/stopprop17
Stop Prop 17 is sponsored by Campaign for Consumer Rights, a nonprofit organization. Campaign for Consumer Rights does not endorse or oppose any candidates for election.
Tags: big corporations, consumer, contributions, Mercury, News Release, Prop 17, trust, voters