Summary of the Mercury Insurance Initiative
Mercury Insurance Is Spending Millions of Dollars to Legalize Premium Hikes That Will Increase the Number of Uninsured Motorists and Raise Taxes
The Mercury Insurance initiative will legalize a surcharge that is currently illegal, but that Mercury imposed anyhow until it was stopped by the courts five years ago. The initiative:
- Allows insurance companies to raise auto insurance prices for customers who didn’t have auto insurance at some point in the past five years, even if they weren’t driving or didn’t have a car.
- Allows insurance companies to raise auto insurance prices for customers who have ever been canceled for missing one payment, even if they restarted their insurance immediately.
- Will lead to higher Uninsured Motorist premiums for all insured drivers.
The Mercury Insurance Initiative Will Raise Auto Insurance Premiums
California law – enacted by the voters in 1988 as part of Proposition 103 – currently prohibits insurance companies from charging customers more just because they didn’t have auto insurance coverage in the past. This unfair practice was common prior to Proposition 103.
The Mercury Insurance initiative would gut this Proposition 103 protection. It will allow insurance companies to raise premiums on drivers who have had a lapse in their coverage of a total of ninety days over the past five years (even if they didn’t need insurance), or didn’t have a car, or whose insurance was canceled after missing a single payment, or who have not purchased auto insurance previously, regardless of their driving safety record.
Mercury Insurance says its initiative will “correct an inconsistency” in the law so insurance companies can “extend a discount,” but these arguments are nonsense. Mercury is sponsoring this initiative so it can increase its profits by penalizing people. In 2002, the Insurance Commissioner determined that this proposal would raise premiums. In 2005, the California Court of Appeal invalidated legislation sponsored by Mercury that was virtually identical to the initiative because the court determined that it would have led to dramatically higher rates for people who were applying for insurance for the first time or had a lapse in coverage.
In other states where these surcharges are allowed, premiums skyrocket. A video at http://StopTheSurcharge.org shows that Mercury Insurance Company raises premiums by 73% on Nevada drivers who had a lapse in coverage for any reason. Nevada allows the practice that Mercury has proposed in this initiative.
The Mercury Initiative Will Increase the Number of Uninsured Motorists and Everyone Else’s Uninsured Motorist Premium and Taxes
The proposed initiative allows insurance companies to charge customers several hundred dollars more for auto insurance if they are applying for coverage but don’t currently have insurance. According to the insurance industry’s own data, hundreds of thousands of Californians will be forced to drop their coverage as a result of the severe recession that has hit California particularly hard. Many of these consumers will not be able to afford to reenter the insurance market as a result of the proposed price hikes. The increase in the number of drivers who cannot afford insurance means that drivers who are insured will pay more for Uninsured Motorist coverage. Moreover, taxpayers will have to pick up the additional costs of more uninsured accidents.
Millions of Californians Would Be Penalized by the Mercury Insurance Initiative
Here are examples of Californians who will face penalties in the range of hundreds of dollars when they buy or restart insurance coverage if the Mercury initiative passes, regardless of whether they are safe drivers:
*A soldier serving on base in the United States would be penalized when he returns to civilian life in California and needs auto insurance again.
*A senior citizen who stops driving for several months after surgery would be penalized when she tries to restart insurance coverage.
*A family who missed a single auto insurance payment and had their coverage cancelled by their insurance company would be penalized even if they tried to restart coverage immediately after they were canceled.
* People who lost their jobs because of the recession and could not afford insurance would be surcharged once they got back on their feet and resumed insurance coverage.
* Students who are away at college and don’t need a car would be penalized when they graduate or buy coverage for the summer. A loophole in the proposal, allows insurers to surcharge young drivers living with parents, above and beyond the already higher rates charged to young drivers.
*Anyone who gives up driving for public transportation or to bike to work would be penalized when they need a car and insurance again.
For more information: Contact the Campaign For Consumer Rights. You can reach us at 310-392-0522 ext. 318 or via e-mail at [email protected].
[...] Summary of the Mercury Insurance Initiative: http://stopthesurcharge.org/2010/01/19/summary/ [...]
[...] Campaign for Consumer Rights released a video at http://StopTheSurcharge.org that shows how a deceptive 2010 ballot initiative sponsored by Mercury Insurance would legalize [...]
[...] Summary of the Mercury Insurance Initiative: http://stopthesurcharge.org/2010/01/19/summary/ [...]
[...] to raise rates on customers who had a lapse in their insurance coverage. In 2005 California courts prevented this from happening. In Nevada, rates increased by 73% on customers with even a day’s lapse in coverage. Mercury [...]