Editorial, THE RECORD SEARCHLIGHT (Redding, CA)
Merry Hyatt’s initiative to require Christmas caroling in California’s public schools was a misguided response to a fabricated problem.
Her drive didn’t come even remotely close to gathering enough signatures to put the measure on the statewide ballot. The petitions barely topped 2,000 names, which wouldn’t even be enough to recall a Redding city councilor, while Hyatt needed more than 400,000.
And voters should consider that a gift. They won’t have to waste their time sorting through one more bad initiative.
That said, just in case a weak thread of doubt lingered in anyone’s mind, the Christmas-carol measure — and the contrast between it and the equally bad measures that do make the ballot — is clear evidence of the rot infecting the initiative system.
The initiative as we know it in California was created 99 years ago by Gov. Hiram Johnson and supported overwhelmingly by the populace as a means to fight the influence of special interests. Onto that noble rootstock, however, the very same special interests have grafted their own tree, whose fruit we see in every election.
Take this June’s ballot, which includes five measures for the voters’ consideration.
The first three — Proposition 13 through 15 — were placed on the ballot by the Legislature. As constitutional issues, they require the voters’ say-so.
Two measures are actual initiatives, where signature-gatherers stood in front of post offices and grocery stores and hustled to gin up interest. But does that mean they sprouted out of grass-roots demand for change? On the contrary.
Proposition 16 is a venture of Pacific Gas & Electric Corp., which has poured tens of millions into a campaign to toughen the votes required before local governments form or expand municipal utilities. Though PG&E’s glossy mailers cast it as a measure to protect taxpayers, its sole purpose is to protect PG&E stockholders and reinforce the utility’s monopoly.
Proposition 17 is a wholly owned subsidiary of Mercury General Corp., an insurance company that has poured more than $3.5 million so far into the effort to change car-insurance regulations. It would allow insurers to reward drivers for maintaining continuous coverage, by any company, and on the flip side charge more for past lapses.
Maybe these measures are even good ideas, but what’s driving them is their sponsors’ business strategies, not the people’s voice.
Does California need a mandate for Christmas carols in schools? No, but it certainly does need reform that will restore the initiative as a tool for the public interest instead of the special interests.
