Here is what Proposition 17 does: A Special -interest measure placed on the ballot by Mercury Insurance Company, which wants the authority to charge higher rates for auto insurance. If approved, Proposition 17 would allow insurers to base their prices in part on a driver’s history of insurance coverage. The companies could increase or lower premiums based upon whether drivers have a history of continuous coverage.
The proponents argue that loosening the rules governing “good driver” discounts would boost competition and lower premiums by as much as $250 a year for the vast majority of motorists. The opponent’s argument is that the initiative is a cynical ploy that actually would result in higher premiums for a certain class of motorists-namely those who haven’t been previously insured or who let their coverage lapse.
As reported in the May 16th Sacramento Bee, this fight has been brewing since 1988 when California passed Proposition 103, the landmark law regulating auto insurance premiums. For years Mercury Insurance has been fighting to roll back a key provision of the law. Proposition 17 is its latest try. Mercury has poured $10milliion into the Prop. 17, mostly for TV ads and is the initiative’s largest financial supporter by far.
Take a look at the official voter guide sent by the Secretary of State. Speaking for the proponents is the Chamber of Commerce among other business groups and for the opposition, former Insurance Commissioner John Garamendi, now a Member of Congress and former Attorney General John Van De Camp. The folks for and against, speak for themselves. Whose company would you prefer to keep?
Now I don’t have any grudge against insurance companies, in fact I have had a great relationship with my carrier for car insurance, State Farm. I had a tree fall on my car that was parked across the street from the Capitol on N Street. A big mess and they were wonderful. No questions asked. I like the service I get from my State Farm agent and pay my premiums monthly which are quite reasonable with no complaints. Mercury Insurance, however, is not a good neighbor.
Does Mercury Insurance remind you of PG&E? When a big corporation tries to manipulate the initiative process for their own self-interest we ought to take a long hard look at the measure.
If Proposition 17 smells to you like Proposition 16 then stop the stench and vote not on Proposition 17.
Tags: big corporations, Blog, consumer, contributions, Mercury, overcharges, Prop 17, trust, voters
