By Mark Glover and Dale Kasler, THE SACRAMENTO BEE
Opponents of Propositions 16 and 17 said Wednesday that the defeat of the two measures was all about money.
Or to be more precise: voter dissatisfaction that Pacific Gas and Electric Co. and Mercury Insurance spent a whopping $60 million combined on the respective measures.
Jack Pitney, a political science professor at Claremont McKenna College, said the lesson is that “if you’re going to win a special-interest initiative, you need a better disguise. The link was too obvious, and the voters smelled a rat.”
Pitney cited the primary victories by Meg Whitman and Carly Fiorina as proof that voters don’t inherently object to business people entering politics.
“People like the idea of free enterprise, but in (Propositions 16 and 17) people sensed that one specific corporation was seeking a benefit for (itself),” he said.
With all precincts statewide reporting, 52.5 percent of voters were giving Proposition 16 a thumbs down. “No” votes on Proposition 17 accounted for 52.1 percent of the total.
While the California secretary of state’s office said “tens of thousands” of absentee ballots are still being counted, political analysts said it’s highly unlikely the results will change.
Out of about 3.85 million votes cast, Proposition 16 trailed by about 185,000 votes. Proposition 17 was failing by about 156,000 votes.
Proposition 16 – formally known as the Taxpayers Right to Vote Act – was put on the California ballot as a constitutional amendment requiring a two-thirds vote before a public utility could extend service to new customers or new territories.
From the beginning, it was spearheaded virtually single-handedly by San Francisco-based PG&E, which spent $46 million to persuade voters to approve it.
Proposition 17 was put on the ballot by Los Angeles-based Mercury Insurance. It would have overturned state law prohibiting insurance companies from considering a driver’s insurance history to set rates. It would have allowed customers to take their “loyalty discounts” with them even if they switched insurance providers.
Mercury spent about $16 million to back the measure.
PG&E insisted that it was simply good policy for voters to have a say when millions of electric customers and taxpayer dollars are on the line. Mercury claimed that Proposition 17 worked to the benefit of millions of Golden State motorists.
Opponents said otherwise. They said the businesses were just trying to shanghai the initiative process to make more money and grab more power.
Proposition 103 author Harvey Rosenfield warned Wednesday that “the initiative process is in danger of being co-opted by big corporations. You had two big corporations trying to enact their business plan as law.”
Gale Kaufman, a campaign consultant for No on 16, said opponents only had about $100,000 to spend, with about $30,000 going into an early poll. She said that poll indicated that Proposition 16 was “losing very convincingly” from the start.
Kaufman said voters didn’t see Proposition 16 as a citizen-empowerment measure, but as a cleverly worded ploy of a single for-profit utility.
“(PG&E’s) biggest miscalculation, besides spending all that money, was that they really thought they could trick people by the phrasing they used on that initiative,” she said.
Kaufman credited an aggressive viral campaign “and a lot of people who did their own thing” for rallying voters against Proposition 16.
Greg Pruett, senior vice president of corporate affairs for PG&E, issued a statement that said, in part: “While the election outcome hasn’t diminished our steadfast belief that citizens should have a vote in local government efforts to enter the electric utility business, we respect the decision voters made on this initiative.”
Mercury Insurance portrayed the defeat of Proposition 17 as a blow to consumers. “Proposition 17 was a pro-consumer initiative that would have lowered auto insurance rates for millions of California drivers,” the company said in a statement.
PG&E Corp. stock closed at $40, down 90 cents, on Wednesday, and Mercury General Corp., the parent of Mercury Insurance, closed at $42.18, down 24 cents. Both are traded on the New York Stock Exchange.
Contact the author at: [email protected]
Tags: big corporations, consumer, contributions, deceptive, Mercury, NewsStory, overcharges, Prop 17, surcharge, trust, voters