Posts Tagged ‘Blog’

Initiative Would Strip Attorney General & Legislature of Power to Write Ballot Title & Summary

February 5th, 2010

By Editor, CALIFORNIA’S CAPITOL BLOG

An initiative awaiting an official title and summary from Attorney General Jerry Brown would transfer the job of creating ballot descriptions to the Legislative Analyst.

The 21st Century Ballot Reform Act”would also forbid the Legislature from writing ballot titles and summaries as well.

Brown – and the Democratic majority Legislature — has been criticized for slanting the title and summary of several ballot measures.

Consumer Watchdog claimed Brown, a likely Democratic candidate for governor, rewrote the title and summary of Proposition 17 on the June ballot to benefit Mercury Insurance which contributed $13,000 to Brown and $3.5 million to place the measure on the ballot.

The proposition would allow insurers to use driving history as a factor in calculating insurance rates, something banned by Proposition 103, a 1988 ballot measure backed by the founder of Consumer Watchdog.

The first title said the measure “allows insurance companies to increase or decrease the cost of auto insurance based on a driver’s coverage history.”  The second title, which came after backers of the initiative amended it reads:

    “Allows auto insurance companies to base their prices in part on a driver’s history of insurance coverage.”

The second version will appear on the ballot.

“This title and summary differs from an earlier one because the substantive text of the two initiatives are different. It has nothing to do with politics,” wrote Jim Humes, Chief Deputy Attorney General, in response to Consumer Watchdog’s claims.

Sen. George Runner, a Lancaster Republican, filed a lawsuit over Brown’s title and summary of an initiative he backs requiring voters to present photo identification.

Brown was also sued by backers of Proposition 8, which bans same sex marriage. They claimed his title and summary was argumentative and prejudicial. A court tossed out the complaint.

On February 3, Brown wrote a title and summary for a measure that would prohibit implementation of AB 32, the landmark greenhouse gas reduction measure until state unemployment falls below 5.5 percent for four one year.

“Suspends air pollution control laws requiring major polluters to report and reduce greenhouse gas emissions that cause global warming until unemployment drops below specified level for full year.”

The description goes on to say that, if approved, the state would “abandon implementation of comprehensive greenhouse-gas-reduction program that includes increased renewable energy and cleaner fuel requirements, and mandatory emission reporting and fee requirements for major polluters such as power plants and oil refineries, until suspension is lifted.”

One of the measure’s backers, Assemblyman Dan Logue, Chico Republican, told Capitol Weekly’s Anthony York “this looks like (Brown) handed this over to the environmental community and asked them to write this summary for them.”

In another recent title and summary of a major overhaul of the state’s budget system that includes two-year budgeting a reduction in the vote requirement from two-thirds to a simple majority Brown said in the title, which is written in bold uppercase letters, that the measure “changes state budget process in several ways.”

The Legislature also has been criticized for writing the title and summary of some measures it passes.

For example, Proposition 15 on the June ballot, a measure by Sen. Loni Hancock, an Oakland Democrat, imposes a fee on lobbyists and their employers to create a fund for public financing of candidates running for Secretary of State.

Toward the end of the measure, the bill orders the Secretary of State to use this title and summary of the proposition.

“CALIFORNIA FAIR ELECTIONS ACT. This act creates a voluntary system for candidates for Secretary of State to qualify for a public campaign grant if they agree to strict spending limits and take no private contributions. Candidates would have to qualify before receiving the grant. Candidates who demonstrate sufficient public support would receive the same amount. Participating candidates would be prohibited from raising or spending money beyond the grant. There would be strict enforcement and accountability with published reports open to the public. Funded by voluntary contributions and by a $350 annual registration fee on lobbyists, lobbying firms, and lobbyist employers.”

The initiative that would turn the task of title and summary over to the Legislative Analyst would also bolster the state’s online ballot pamphlet by adding links to the most recent campaign finance reports, websites of supporters and opponents of a ballot measure and video or audio presentations requested by the authors of the ballot arguments for and against the measure.

Received by Brown’s office January 19, it has yet to receive a title and summary.

Jim Conran's "Consumers First" is Just One of His Many Front Groups

February 3rd, 2010

Mercury Insurance may not be great to its employees (you may remember last year Mercury laid off 363 of its workers), but its campaign consultants make a mint.

No wonder Kathy Fairbanks — the spokeswoman for Cal-FAIR -- the Mercury Insurance ballot initiative (Prop 17) mouthpiece — keeps at it for Mercury Insurance. In fact, looks like her firm, Bicker, Castillo & Fairbanks has raked in almost $200,000 since last August. Not a bad chunk of change for six months work. But, she’s not the only one.

Jim Conran in his latest incarnation as head of Consumers First, Inc. has not done too badly working for Mercury’s execs. I mean its not Fairbank’s kind of money, but $5,000 a month for helping out George Joseph, the billionaire chairman of Mercury Insurance,  is nothing to sniff at in these tough times.  Especially since Mr. Conran, much like Ms. Fairbanks, has worked on or continues to work on all sorts of front group projects:

Mr. Conran is listed as the executive director, Consumers for Cable Choice. His partner in this and other front groups is Bob Johnson, an Indiana lawyer who apparently represents nearly two-dozen telecom firms. Leveraging clients at the expense of consumers, clever;

Mr. Conran is listed as the executive director for Consumers for Competitive Choice;

Mr. Conran is listed at the co-chair for Californians for Fair Auto Insurance Rates (Cal-FAIR) coalition. (He is working overtime for Mercury);

Mr. Conran is listed as the, you guessed it, executive director of the Child Safety TaskForce with again, his friend, Bob Johnson. (This is one of my favorite of his front groups. It is particularly craven. I will have more on that in my upcoming posts);

Mr. Conran also runs Credit Card Con, a project of Consumers for Competitive Choice;

Mr. Conran also heads up the Citizens to Stop the Power Grab Coalition (the website has been pulled down, but its goal is stated as: “Stop Eminent Domain Abuse in Manteca, Ripon and Escalon”) and;

Mr. Conran also helps out Truth About Splenda.

Now, we can’t know what Mr. Conran is being paid for all of these altruistic activities, but if he is cashing in from the industry folks that fund his other work, anything like Mercury’s monthly checks to him, he is doing a-okay in this economy.

Prop. 17 = Mercury Insurance Deceptive Ballot Measure

February 1st, 2010

by Naomi Seligman

Today, the Mercury Insurance ballot initiative was assigned a number, Prop. 17, by California Secretary of State Debra Bowen for the June 8 ballot. We here at the Campaign for Consumer Rights are ready to fight this unfair, opportunistic measure.

Prop. 17 is fully funded by Mercury Insurance to jack up Californians’ auto insurance premiums. Proposition 17 would surcharge drivers, including soldiers and seniors, who have had a lapse in car insurance coverage for virtually any reason during the past five years.

Under the proposal, people who stopped driving and didn’t need insurance for a time would be required to pay hundreds of dollars more for insurance when they sought to restart coverage. Prop. 17 would also allow insurers to charge significantly higher premiums to people who missed just one insurance payment.

The measure would gut a provision of the 1988 insurance reform measure Proposition 103, which prohibits companies from raising rates on people because they did not have auto insurance in the past.

Harvey Rosenfield, the founder of Consumer Watchdog and the author of Prop. 103, had this to say today:

Don’t be fooled by Proposition 17 and the multi-million dollar campaign funded by Mercury Insurance. Prop 17 is an insurance company attack on families, soldiers and seniors who are already struggling in a tough economy. Voters should know that Prop 17 will raise insurance premiums.

Mercury Insurance executives are paying millions upon millions of dollars to make sure that you pay more out of your budget to drive your car. And Mercury is not an honest broker. It’s executives are hiding behind a  front group called Cal-FAIR to run its campaign behind closed doors.

To learn more or join us in beating back Prop. 17, please visit http://StopTheSurcharge.org.

Meet the Spokeswoman for the Mercury Initiative

January 29th, 2010

by Naomi Seligman

This week, Insurance Journal wrote a piece on the Mercury Insurance initiative based partly on messaging from Kathy Fairbanks, a paid PR consultant working at the beshest of…you guessed it, Mercury Insurance. To discuss the initiative with reporters, Ms. Fairbanks uses the guise as spokeswoman for Californians for Fair Auto Insurance Rates or CAL-FAIR — a front group Mercury has set up and funded for its deceptive initiative campaign.

Actually, Ms. Fairbanks works for a PR firm called Bicker, Castillo & Fairbanks, a public affairs firm specializing in issues management, grassroots advocacy and media relations.

The firm’s principles, Gwyn Bicker, Brandon Castillo and Kathy Fairbanks, have collectively managed more than a dozen successful local and statewide ballot initiative campaigns, and have been involved in numerous issues management, crisis communications and legislative grassroots and media support projects in the past decade. Issues addressed by the firm include: the environment, taxation, bonds, transportation, growth and development, government regulation and reform, local government finance, education, gaming, health care, energy and insurance, to name a few.

Seeing her quoted so frequently, we took a look at her bio to get a better sense of her experience.

Kathy Fairbanks has specialized in developing, managing and implementing media relations and communications strategies for a broad range of clients whose policy concerns include education, healthcare, public safety, local government, insurance, housing, environmental and business issues.

Okay, so not a lot of time spent on the meat of the issues. Maybe she worked for an Insurance Commissioner or an auto insurer?

Ms. Fairbanks has experience managing communications plans and message development for literally dozens of legislative and regulatory advocacy campaigns as well as on statewide ballot initiative campaigns. Recent ballot initiative campaigns include the following successes: No on Proposition 90 (eminent domain/regulatory takings-November 2006); No on Prop. 82 (tax increase/universal preschool-June 2006); Yes on Prop. 1A (local government funding protection-November 2004); Yes on Prop. 55 (statewide school construction bond-March 2004); Yes on Prop. 40 (statewide parks, water and resources bond-March 2002); No on Prop. 9 (electric utility deregulation-November 1998); and No on Props. 214 and 216 (mandated health care-November 1996).

Guess not.

See The Mercury Surcharge In Action

January 28th, 2010

More Proof Mercury Init Raises Insurance Premiums

January 26th, 2010

Ready for a 227% Increase in Your Car Insurance?

January 22nd, 2010

Even I can’t believe this!

Mercury Insurance Company has been telling everyone that their June ballot initiative will not raise people’s auto insurance premiums. But the company’s own website proves Mercury is lying.

Watch the video I made when I went on Mercury’s web site.

I plugged in a zip code for Nevada, where state law allows insurance companies to penalize motorists in ways California doesn’t, and lo and behold! In Nevada, consumers who Mercury doesn’t want to insure get smashed with a 73% increase in their insurance rates under the provision the company wants to legalize in California.

In Florida, it’s 227%!

Mercury’s ballot initiative will legalize these kinds of surcharges in California – surcharges that we outlawed with Proposition 103 in 1988.

Mercury also lied about its initiative to Attorney General Jerry Brown – who is required by law to publish an independent and objective summary of the Mercury Initiative that will appear on the ballot – and he believed them!

Attorney General Jerry Brown must give voters the full story about the Mercury Initiative. Take a moment to call (916-324-5437) or write Brown and let him know you are depending on him to tell voters that premium increases are coming if Mercury’s initiative passes.

You could be hit with surcharges if you ever missed a payment. You’ll pay more if you or a member of your family, at any time during the last five years, dropped coverage while away at school, hospitalized or because you sold your car or didn’t need insurance for any reason. Or if you are one of the hundreds of thousands of Californians who are forced to stop driving because the economy is so bad. Mercury even wants to surcharge people who didn’t have car insurance while serving in the military in the United States.

You can learn more about Mercury’s deceptive ballot measure at StopTheSurcharge.org.

You shouldn’t be penalized if you’ve done nothing wrong. For twenty-two years, Proposition 103 has protected you against swindles like this. Now Mercury wants a get-out-of-jail-free card. Please help me stop them. Sign up to become part of our campaign and send us a donation at StopTheSurcharge.org.

Many thanks,

Harvey Rosenfield

Author of Prop 103

10 Reasons You Cannot Trust Mercury Insurance Company

January 19th, 2010

Mercury Insurance is spending millions of dollars to pass an initiative that will legalize a surcharge that is currently illegal, but that Mercury imposed anyhow until it was stopped by the courts five years ago.  Mercury wants Californians to believe that the initiative is not a power-grab and that it will not harm consumers, won’t raise premiums for good drivers and won’t lead to more uninsured motorists; but Mercury cannot be trusted.

There are plenty of reasons not to trust Mercury Insurance.  Here are 10 reasons adapted from a list compiled last year by the nonpartisan organization Consumer Watchdog, a nonprofit group affiliated with Campaign for Consumer Rights.

1. State regulators describe Mercury Insurance as an abusive, anti-consumer company.

The California Department of Insurance recently made this statement before an Administrative Law Judge in an agency enforcement action against Mercury:

Mercury’s lengthy history of serious misconduct, and its attitude – contempt towards and/or abuse of its customers, the Commissioner, its competition, and the Superior Court – are all relevant to determining the penalty needed to best ensure the protection of the public from future violations and wrongdoing…

Among Department [of Insurance] staff, consumer attorneys, and consumer victims of its bad faith, Mercury has a deserved reputation for abusing its customers and intentionally violating the law with arrogance and indifference.

The statement came in a brief submitted by the Department of Insurance in February 2009 in response to a motion by Mercury to exclude evidence of the company’s past conduct.

  • See key pages from that brief here. (See, particularly, page 4.)
  • Read the “Notice of Noncompliance” in the administrative proceeding filed by the Department of Insurance here.

2.  Mercury illegally surcharged hundreds of thousands of drivers until it was ordered to stop in 2005.

For years, Mercury Insurance illegally overcharged hundreds of thousands of California drivers hundreds of dollars per year, until they were forced to stop in the wake of a Court of Appeal decision in 2005.  Despite California’s unambiguous prohibition against using someone’s history of prior insurance coverage to determine premiums, Mercury Insurance penalized drivers who had a lapse in their auto insurance for any reason, bringing in millions of dollars through an illegal surcharge.

Mercury was sued by its customers for this illegal charge (Donabedian v. Mercury), but continued to impose the surcharge even as it was lobbying Sacramento to delete the prohibition from California’s insurance reform law, Proposition 103.   Only in 2005, after the California Court of Appeal confirmed earlier rulings that the surcharge and a law allowing the surcharge were illegal, did Mercury finally stop penalizing good drivers just because they had a lapse in auto insurance coverage.

The Mercury Insurance initiative headed to the 2010 California ballot would legalize the premium increases Mercury had finally been forced to stop charging.

3. An internal training manual produced in a civil trial shows Mercury Insurance trained employees to mistreat, neglect and even threaten customers who file claims.

A Mercury instructional guide for employees told claims processors how to delay and lowball claims, and to “remind” customers that if they tried to hold Mercury accountable in court for such mistreatment, they could end up losing. Some of the training provided to Mercury claims staff in the manual included:

  • “Never use your top dollar to begin negotiations”
  • “Use time as your ally”
  • “Remind claimants that a judge or jury would find them at comparative fault”

A portion of the instructional guide was disclosed as part of a 2006 lawsuit against the company by a Los Angeles business that sued Mercury for failing to properly pay a claim. During the lawsuit, a Mercury employee asserted that the company no longer uses the training manual. As the Daily Journal in 2008:

Mark Volper and Boris Smorodinski claimed their Sherman Oaks business suffered a slow “death by asphyxiation” while Mercury repeatedly denied their claims and ignored pleading letters for help.

The unanimous decision came last week after jurors were shown internal training guides instructing Mercury adjustors to low-ball customers, drag out their claims and remind them they could be found at fault in a trial. Amerigraphics Inc. v. Mercury Casualty Company BC331524 (L.A. Super. Ct., Feb. 21, 2008).

Read the Daily Journal article about the lawsuit here.

4. Mercury had to be forced by a California court to stop its insurance agents from charging illegal broker fees to unsuspecting customers.

In 2003, the San Francisco Superior Court found that Mercury was deceiving customers through its advertising by suggesting that consumers would pay less for auto insurance from Mercury than from other insurance companies. What its ad campaign failed to disclose was that Mercury customers (unlike the comparison companies) would often be required to pay an additional broker fee that is illegal under California law, driving up the actual price. The court issued an injunction ordering Mercury to change its practices.

  • Read the judge’s conclusions about how Mercury deceived customers here.
  • Read the judge’s refusal to lift the injunction against Mercury over this practice here.

5. In 2008, Mercury paid the California Department of Insurance a quarter-million dollar settlement for alleged claims handling violations.

People often buy insurance by looking at price. But if a company has a history of failing to handle consumers’ claims properly after an accident or a loss — the moment they need their insurance most — then a low premium isn’t such a great deal. The California Department of Insurance investigated Mercury’s claims handling practices, a matter Mercury settled by paying $250,000 (plus the Department’s enforcement and legal costs) and agreeing to pay more penalties if they didn’t improve their practices in six months. The Department of Insurance explained the problem with Mercury in a June 2008 news release:

The California Department of Insurance (CDI) conducted a review of consumer complaints filed with the Department against Mercury Insurance, Mercury Casualty, and California Automobile Insurance Companies, collectively known as Mercury Insurance Group. Of the 121 files reviewed, a total of 258 violations were discovered to have occurred from January 2004 through December 2005. These violations involved several of the company’s claims-handling practices, including unreasonable delays in affirming or denying coverage and issuing claim payments.

Read the Department of Insurance news release here.

6. Mercury Insurance was ordered by Florida regulators to pay $2 million to consumers and $1 million to the state for improperly denying legitimate claims and repeatedly flouting the law.

Mercury is not only in the crosshairs of California regulators. In 2006, Mercury was investigated and punished by the Florida Office of Insurance Regulation “after receiving a steady increase in complaints from Florida Mercury policyholders.” As the state regulator’s news release explains:

The examination found a multitude of violations relating to the companies’ business practices including the unwarranted termination of policies upon the filing of a claim, failing to pay the full amount on covered claims, failing to deliver policies within 60 days, failing to provide specific reasons for denial of claims, and the use of unappointed agents. However, it was the use of unfiled forms and rates to improperly deny claims that the Office considered to be the most egregious violation.

  • Read the Florida Office of Insurance Regulation release here.
  • Read the insurance publication Best Week story “Florida Orders Mercury General Units to Pay More than $2 Million to Policyholders” here.

7. According to a smoking gun document, Mercury pays its repair shops incentives to use aftermarket parts.

Consumer Watchdog has obtained an internal Mercury document that exposes the company’s secret practice of paying its recommended auto repair shops incentives — up to $750 — to use aftermarket and reconditioned parts and penalizes its repair shops for using original manufacturer parts. According to the document, Mercury pays body shops 20% more than the shop paid for non-manufacturer parts, while it pays 5% less than the body shop’s own cost for original manufacturer’s parts. Incentivizing repair shops to use inferior parts when repairing policyholders’ cars endangers policyholders even if it may save Mercury money and increase profits. It is believed that the internal document was issued recently and reflects the current arrangement between Mercury and its body shops.

Read the document here.

8. Mercury Insurance has a long history of trying to thwart consumer protections and the will of the voters in the state legislature and on the ballot.

Ever since California voters enacted the landmark insurance reform initiative Proposition 103 in 1988, Mercury Insurance has led a series of efforts to undermine or repeal its consumer protections. Mercury’s commitment to undermining California’s consumer protections was summed up in June 2009 by Los Angeles Times columnist Michael Hiltzik, who wrote:

No one’s been more determined to rewrite Proposition 103 than Mercury and its founder and chairman, George Joseph. The 87-year-old Joseph is known for detesting Proposition 103, and for not being reluctant to spend millions of dollars to rewrite it.

[http://www.latimes.com/business/la-fi-hiltzik2-2009jul02,0,1795869.column]

Over the years Mercury has sponsored at least eight bills in the California Legislature to repeal or override key consumer protections approved by the voters. These include attempts to gut the 20% Good Driver Discount requirement, to re-impose discriminatory ZIP Code-based auto insurance pricing, to add new surcharges on customers, and to prevent courts and the Insurance Commissioner from ordering refunds when insurers violate the law.

Read more about Mercury’s efforts in Sacramento to dismantle Prop 103 here.

Mercury has also tried to go to the ballot in order to strip Californians of consumer protections.  The 2010 initiative is not Mercury’s first attempt.

In 2006, Mercury proposed an initiative to gut other parts of California’s landmark insurance reform measure, Proposition 103. It would have allowed, among other things, insurers to rate drivers primarily on their ZIP Code rather than driving safety record. After sparking a public outcry, the proposal was withdrawn.  Read the Los Angeles Times article describing Mercury’s 2006 attempt to attack Proposition 103 here.

9. Mercury Insurance is a leader among California auto insurers in one respect: political contributions.

Over the past ten years, Mercury has given more money directly to California state politicians and to California political parties than any of the four other largest auto insurers (State Farm, Farmers, Allstate, and Auto Club of SoCal), according to data available from the California Secretary of State. In fact, just considering donations directly from these insurers, Mercury has given more to individuals and parties between 1999 and 2008 ($2,746,600) than all four companies combined ($2,266,750), even though State Farm, Farmers and Allstate are substantially larger insurance corporations.

Download a spreadsheet summarizing the donations by California’s largest auto insurers here and a pivot table for a detailed comparison at here.

A key reason that Mercury has been such a prolific political donor in California is that it has hoped to wield influence over state politicians as part of its ongoing efforts to undermine the state’s insurance consumer protection laws, such as Proposition 103 (see #6 above).

In 2000, around the time that it was facing a potential enforcement action by the California Department of Insurance, Mercury made a major donation to then-Commissioner Chuck Quackenbush. As Insurance Journal reported the story:

California Insurance Chuck Quackenbush received a $50,000 campaign contribution from the head of Mercury Insurance Group less than two weeks after regulators froze a proposed enforcement action against the company. Both George Joseph, Mercury CEO, and Deputy Commissioner Dan Edwards agreed that the contribution was not linked to the proposed enforcement action.

The Wall Street Journal reported that in January, California Department of Insurance (CDI) officials in January threatened Mercury and five related insurance units with fines. Authorities alleged that some of Mercury’s independent brokers improperly charged customers fees, mostly for the purchase of auto-liability and property-damage coverage. According to Joseph, the fines were put on the back burner during a meeting between Mercury and department officials.

[http://www.insurancejournal.com/news/west/2000/05/12/11992.htm]

Chuck Quackenbush resigned in disgrace later that year in the wake of this and other improprieties that were revealed in the news media. A decade later, Mercury is finally facing a Department hearing on the broker fee practices that were going to be the subject of the canceled 2000 proceeding.  (See #1 above.)

10. Mercury Insurance and its Chairman have been mentioned during two FBI investigations into California political corruption.

In 1991, when the FBI was investigating corruption in the California Capitol that later led to the imprisonment of State Senator Alan Robbins and insurance lobbyist Clay Jackson, wiretaps of conversations between the two often referred to Mercury’s founder and Chairman George Joseph. In one frank exchange, Mercury’s chief was suggested as a possible donor, because he needed some legislative help from the Senator in his campaign to undermine provisions of Proposition 103, the voter approved reform initiative:

Senator Alan Robbins (AR): Okay. ‘Cause it would be…very, very…helpful if, uh, the check were here when I, uh, got back Tuesday night. Were here Wednesday morning.

Lobbyist Clay Jackson (CJ): Maybe. But, uh, I’ve been doing a lot of talking to George Joseph lately. He just applied for membership in the AIA [American Insurance Association, an industry lobbying group]. Which is just to get me.

AR: A wise move on his part.

CJ: Yes. And, uh, but aside from that, George is ready to do something, maybe George is the angel to ride to the rescue here.

AR: Maybe. What is George, uh, looking for?

CJ: Help. And when you’re flat on your back, you’ll grasp for anything you got. And right now, uh, you know, what he has done in the last six months, what he’s tried to do up here, remember years and years ago we always had uh, a couple little George Joseph bills that tinkered here and tinkered there.

AR: Yeah

CJ: He’s back to that.

AR: Okay.

[From transcript of September 5, 1991 8:28 am meeting between Alan Robbins & Clayton Jackson]

That wouldn’t be the last time Mercury and George Joseph’s name came up in federal investigations. As the San Francisco Chronicle reported in 2004, Mercury’s sponsorship of a bill to gut the same provision of Proposition 103 that is being attacked by its 2010 initiative was raised in the context of an FBI inquiry into Senator Don Perata:

George Joseph, the chief executive of Mercury, acknowledged in an interview Tuesday that a Sacramento investment fund in which he is a partner has received a federal subpoena related to the Perata inquiry. But he said Mercury itself has not received a subpoena.

At Mercury’s request, Perata carried legislation in 2003 that allowed insurers to impose surcharges on drivers who previously lacked insurance or had allowed their coverage to lapse. Though the measure was signed into law, it was thrown out by a judge because it conflicted with the state Constitution.

[http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/c/a/2004/11/24/MNGDHA0PPK1.DTL]

It is noteworthy that Mercury donated at least $175,000 to then-Governor Davis’s anti-recall campaign a few weeks after he signed the 2003 bill on Mercury’s behalf. Consumer Watchdog’s news release on the donation to Davis can be viewed here.

Summary of the Mercury Insurance Initiative

January 19th, 2010

Mercury Insurance Is Spending Millions of Dollars on Prop 17 To Surcharge Good Drivers In Tough Times

Prop 17 would allow insurance companies to raise insurance prices by imposing premium surcharges that are currently illegal. The initiative:

  1. Allows insurance companies to raise auto insurance prices up to $1,000/year for customers who didn’t have auto insurance at some point in the past five years, even if they weren’t driving or didn’t have a car.
  2. Allows insurance companies to raise auto insurance prices for customers who have ever been canceled for missing one payment, even if they restarted their insurance immediately.
  3. Will lead to higher Uninsured Motorist premiums for all insured drivers.

Prop 17 says one thing, but does another.

Mercury Insurance says the initiative is simply to allow companies to hand out discounts to customers.  When was the last time a big insurance company spent millions to save consumers money? Prop 17 actually guts a key consumer protection, reducing accountability for insurance companies so they can raise premiums.

Who Does Proposition 17 Target?

  • A soldier serving on base in the United States would be penalized when he returns to civilian life in California and needs auto insurance.
  • If someone loses their job and cannot afford insurance or even a car for a time, they would be surcharged when they get back on their feet and try to get insurance.
  • A senior citizen who stops driving for several months after surgery would be penalized when she tries to shop for new insurance coverage.
  • A family whose coverage was canceled after missing just one auto insurance payment would be penalized even if they tried to restart coverage immediately after they were canceled.
  • Anyone who gives up their car for car sharing or to bike to work or relies on public transportation would be penalized when they need a car and insurance again.
  • Students who are away at college and don’t need a car would be penalized when they graduate and need a car to enter the workforce.
  • Everyone buying auto insurance for the first time would pay the Prop 17 surcharge.

If Prop 17 passes, there will be more uninsured drivers, raising premiums for all drivers.

Vote No on Prop 17
/

Myth vs. Facts

January 19th, 2010

Myth: The Mercury Insurance initiative will lower insurance premiums for Californians.

Fact: The initiative is written and funded by Mercury Insurance in order to allow the company to raise insurance prices by imposing penalties and surcharges that are illegal now. The initiative could raise premiums for drivers who did not carry auto insurance coverage in the past, even if they didn’t have a car, by hundreds of dollars. And by making auto insurance more expensive, the Mercury Insurance initiative will lead to more people driving uninsured, which will result in premium hikes for the rest of us.

Myth: This initiative only allows auto insurance companies to give discounts.

Fact: There is no free lunch under California insurance laws. Every “discount” must be “balanced” by a surcharge.  Those who do not qualify for the “discount” Mercury Insurance is promising must, by law, pay a surcharge to ensure the company has enough premiums to pay claims. Both the Insurance Commissioner and the courts have determined that Mercury’s proposal will lead to higher premiums for many motorists. And when drivers can’t afford to buy the higher priced insurance, everyone else will make up the difference through higher Uninsured Motorist premiums.

Mercury Insurance Company says it is sponsoring this measure so it can lower its rates. But when Mercury Insurance broke California law and illegally charged Californians the surcharge its is proposing in this measure, it raised customers’ premiums by more than 40%.  Tests of Mercury Insurance online premium quotes in other states, where this surcharge is legal, show price hikes as high as 90%.

Myth: This initiative just fixes an “inconsistency” in California law.

Fact: Mercury Insurance’s initiative targets a key consumer protection in Proposition 103,the insurance reform initiative passed by California voters in 1988. The purpose of that section of California law (Insurance Code Section 1861.02(c)) is to prohibit insurance companies from charging drivers more just because they previously did not have auto insurance coverage, even if they had an excellent safety record.

Mercury Insurance claims that its initiative doesn’t punish any drivers based on their prior insurance coverage and doesn’t undermine Insurance Code Section 1861.02(c). .  In fact, the first line of the Mercury initiative states:  “Notwithstanding section 1861.02(c).“

Mercury Insurance wants voters to think this is a minor tweak to law, but when the California Court of Appeal invalidated a virtually identical law enacted by the Legislature in 2003 (SB 841), the Court ruled that the proposal was not a minor change but in direct conflict with Proposition 103:

Whereas the voters [through Proposition 103] had prohibited insurers from using the absence of prior insurance coverage as a premium criterion to promote fairness for previously uninsured drivers now required to purchase insurance under California law, Sen. Bill 841 authorizes insurers to use that criterion to determine whether a policyholder’s premium will be discounted or surcharged. [Emphasis in original] citation

In 2007 Mercury settled a civil lawsuit after it was found that the company was violating Proposition 103 and illegally surcharging customers by tens of millions of dollars.  Mercury’s proposed initiative would legalize the illegal surcharges for which it was sued.  The insurance giant is not spending millions of dollars in order to lower prices; it could do that without an initiative.

Myth: Setting premiums based on“continuous coverage” is the same as using “persistency” or “loyalty.”

Fact: Mercury is trying to deceive the voters with the same arguments that have been rejected by the California Insurance Commissioner and the courts.

An insurance company is currently allowed to charge customers less after they have been with the company for several years.  This discount for a customer’s “loyalty” is called a “persistency” discount by insurance company actuaries and is associated with the reduced cost of renewing and underwriting long-term customers.  People who have not been with the insurer for long enough, or are new to the company  are not considered “loyal” and are not eligible for the loyalty discount.

The Mercury Insurance initiative has nothing to do with whether a customer has been loyal.  This proposal adds a “rating factor” for setting auto insurance premiums that will raise or lower customers’ premiums based on whether or not they were previously insured by another company or had a break in insurance coverage during the past five years.  This has nothing to do with motorists’ driving records or the costs associated with providing insurance.  Mercury’s initiative targets people who didn’t have or need insurance coverage in the past or who had a lapse for military service, sickness or other reason, and forces them to pay higher premiums

Myth: This initiative is led by a coalition called Cal-FAIR and supported by consumer groups.

Fact: Mercury Insurance Company, a Los Angeles based firm that has consistently broken California’s insurance laws, wrote and is the sole financial supporter of this initiative.

In support of penalizing Mercury for its unlawful practices, the California Department of Insurance has this to say about the company: “Among Department staff, consumer attorneys, and consumer victims of its bad faith, Mercury has a deserved reputation for abusing its customers and intentionally violating the law with arrogance and indifference…. Mercury’s lengthy history of serious misconduct, and its attitude – contempt towards and/or abuse of its customers, the Commissioner, its competition, and the Superior Court – are all relevant to determining the penalty needed to best ensure the protection of the public from future violations and wrongdoing.”

As of January 15, 2010, Mercury spent over $4.5 million dollars. Because Mercury has such a bad reputation, a large portion of that money was used to hire public public relations experts to create a phony front group called Cal-FAIR.  Another consultant hired by Mercury is Jim Conran, who operates a fictional group called “Consumers First.” Conran is often paid by insurance companies, utilities, and oil and gas firms to pretend he is a consumer advocate. The corporate public relations firm of Goddard Claussen – well known for working for the insurance industry – is also involved.

Consumer groups that actually fight for consumer rights such as Consumer Watchdog, Consumer Federation of California, Consumer Federation of America and United Policyholders oppose the initiative.

For more information: Contact the Campaign For Consumer Rights. You can reach us at 310-392-0522 ext. 318 or via e-mail at [email protected].