Posts Tagged ‘Blog’

Mercury Insurance Company Has Sued to Silence Me!

March 4th, 2010

Wow! Mercury Insurance has sued to stop me, former Attorney General John Van De Kamp, and former Insurance Commissioner John Garamendi from warning the public in the Official State Voter Guide about the huge premium increases to come under Mercury’s Prop 17 for millions of drivers.

Mercury also says it’s going to court against Attorney General Jerry Brown, who has just issued his official analysis of Prop 17 for the Voter Guide. Brown states clearly that 17 will allow insurance companies to raise premiums for those who have a lapse in their auto insurance coverage or missed a single insurance payment.

We already knew this corrupt insurance company would spend tens of millions of dollars to lie to voters about Prop 17 — it spent $3.5 million just to stick the measure on the June ballot. Now Mercury is trying to censor our views and deceive the voters–using taxpayers’ money.

We’re not going to let Mercury get away with it! Today we filed our own lawsuit against Mercury, asking the courts to strike the devious lies and tricks that Mercury wants to put in Voter Guide. You can read the lawsuit here.

The showdown over our right to tell voters the truth about Prop 17 will be in Sacramento Superior Court on Friday March 12th. I am confident of complete victory, but we could sorely use your help to support the legal team we have had to hire to fight back against Mercury’s attempt to keep voters in the dark about its dangerous Prop 17.

Please make a contribution today to our legal defense fund and the campaign to stop Prop 17. You can read the ballot arguments we are suing to protect here.

Thanks again for all your support,

Harvey Rosenfield

Consumer Watchdog Founder, and Author of Prop 103

Stop Prop 17 Coalition Partners

March 3rd, 2010

Stop Prop 17 Coalition Partners

California Federation of Teachers

Service Employees International Union (SEIU)

California Labor Federation

California Nurses Association

VoteVets.org

California Alliance for Retired Americans

Consumers Union, non-profit publisher of Consumer Reports

Consumer Action

Consumer Federation of California

Consumers for Automobile Reliability and Safety

United PolicyHolders

Alameda County Central Labor Council

San Mateo Country Central Labor Council

Los Angeles County Democratic Central Committee

Alameda County Democratic Central Committee

Fresno County Democratic Central Committee

San Francisco County Democratic Central Committee

San Mateo County Democratic Central Committee

Dolores Huerta

Congressman John Garamendi

John Van de Kamp, Former California Attorney General

Assemblyman Hector De La Torre

Assemblyman Dave Jones

To join the opposition against Prop 17, please contact Naomi Seligman at 310.392.0522 ext 318 or [email protected].

False and misleading lawsuit

February 25th, 2010

By Naomi Seligman

Talk about irony: Mercury Insurance and its front group Cal-FAIR have filed a lawsuit in Sacramento today attacking the ballot argument against Proposition 17 as “false and misleading.” Really? Seems Mercury and Cal-FAIR win top prize in that category. Their endless stream of lies, hyperbole, and distortions boggle the mind. To say it is disingenuous would be generous, to a fault.

The 62-page lawsuit – over our 750 words — filed by Mercury’s campaign committee asks a Sacramento judge to strikeout or rewrite large portions of the arguments against Prop 17, which were wrtten by consumer and veterans advocates as well as former Insurance Commissioner John Garamendi and former Attorney General John Van de Kamp. Click here to download a copy of the lawsuit.

Proposition 17, sponsored and funded by Mercury Insurance, would allow insurance companies to surcharge drivers based on their history of purchasing auto insurance. That is currently illegal in California by virtue of the 1988 insurance reform measure Proposition 103.

Mercury’s Proposition 17 suit claims that Proposition 103 does not ban consideration of prior insurance coverage history, notwithstanding numerous decisions by CA Dept. of Insurance and the courts in the past.

In its lawsuit, Mercury asks the Court to change or delete 10 sections from the 500-word argument against Prop 17 and three sections from the 250-word rebuttal.

The argument against Prop 17 was signed by Consumer Watchdog, Consumers Union, the nonprofit publisher of Consumer Reports and VoteVets.org.

Harvey Rosenfield, the founder of Consumer Watchdog had this to say when he read the suit:

Mercury Insurance is lying to the Court, just as it has been lying to voters and has lied to regulators, lawmakers and the courts in the past. This lawsuit is a total waste of court resources, but Mercury will spend any amount of money to have its way and deny the public honest information about its attack on responsible drivers who can’t afford Prop 17’s premium hikes.

Mercury wants to win the surcharge battle, at any price.

For more information about Prop 17, visit: www.StopProp17.org

Jerry Brown gets it right on Prop 17's Title & Summary

February 24th, 2010

Jerry Brown gets it right on Prop 17’s Title & Summary

by Jamie Court

California Attorney General Jerry Brown has issued his final ballot label for Proposition 17, the Mercury Insurance-financed ballot measure to surcharge those with lapses in auto insurance coverage.  Brown got the ballot label right this time, acknowledging Prop 17 allowed insurers to increase premiums, as well as lower prices, based on whether a driver has a lapse in insurance coverage.

Ballot measure labels are crucial because they often are all voters have to go on before casting a vote, and Mercury Insurance is sure to spend $10 million to convince voters there’s no premium increases involved in Prop 17.

Brown drew big fire in the media when in October he altered an earlier version of the ballot title and summary from August to omit the earlier reference to premium increases. When Brown’s communications director tried to kill a story in the San Francisco Chronicle talking about the change and a contribution to Brown from Mercury Insurance, the reporter discovered her conversation was being taped without her knowledge. This led to the spokesperson’s resignation.

In today’s final ballot version Brown tells the full story behind Prop 17.  See the original title prepared by Brown from August, the altered October version, and the final ballot label, which voters see in the booth,  and final ballot pamplet summary released today. The arguments for and against in the ballot pamplet can be found here.  Find out more about the campaign against Prop 17 at StopProp17.org

Jerry Brown deserves credit for doing his homework and getting this complicated issue right for voters.

Prop 17 Opposition Arguments

February 23rd, 2010

Today, Secretary of State Debra Bowen made publicly available the Prop 17 ballot arguments and rebuttals.

Prop 17 Title and Summary:
http://www.campaignforconsumerrights.org/resources/title-summary-prop-17.pdf

Ballot Argument Against Mercury’s Prop 17:
http://www.campaignforconsumerrights.org/resources/arg-against-prop-17.pdf

Rebuttal Argument to Mercury’s Prop 17:
http://www.campaignforconsumerrights.org/resources/rebut-arg-in-favor-prop-17.pdf

Our argument was signed by Elisa Odabashian, Director of the West Coast Office of Consumer Union and Jon Soltz, Chair of VoteVets.org, which represents 100,00 veterans and their families.

Our  rebuttal was signed by former Insurance Commissioner John Garamendi and John Van de Kamp, the former Attorney General. Garamendi was the first to win the office of Insurance Commissioner, made an elective post by Prop. 103. Garamendi delivered $1.2 billion in refund checks during his first term, and successfully defeated an earlier attempt by Mercury to engage in the practices that Prop. 17 would legalize. As Attorney General, John Van de Kamp successfully defended Proposition 103 in the courts after insurance companies sued to block the law from taking effect the day after Election Day in November, 1988.

Debates Raging Over Proposed Auto Insurance Law in California

February 12th, 2010

By Jeanny Hopper, AUTOQUOTENOW.COM

Even before the controversial Continuous Coverage Auto Insurance Discount Act goes into ballot on June 8, debates among proponents of the law and those against it have already ensued to obtain popular opinion among California residents.

Consumer Watchdog, a non-profit group which advocates consumer and taxpayer interests, disclosed that voters may be fooled by the real purpose of the proposed statute. It even prompted Harvey Rosenfield, founder of the group, to state that the new legislation is fraudulent and full of deception.

The main contention of Consumer Watchdog is that the initiative is nothing but an attempt to hike insurance costs. Rosenfield said that even with just questioning and calling to ask for coverage rules, rates could go up under the proposed initiative.

Rosenfield also explained that on the instance of a vehicular mishap, even the motorist who is not at fault could also be penalized. Add to this, if a consumer had failed to pay premiums or have lapses in payment, penalties would be allowed to be charged against said consumer. This provision, in turn, would also affect members of the military assigned abroad who could not make payments on time because of the distance.

Rosenfield even contends that amidst the gathering of campaign signatures, “paid signature gatherers” would roam supermarkets and other public places to “confuse” voters into approving the initiative. Said signature gatherers, according to him, receive 75 cents to a dollar for every signature of approval.

As to the real proponent, he said that the real sponsor is the auto insurance company Mercury Insurance. Even if the proposed law is signed by Christina Wilson, he contends that the real person behind the move is George Joseph, chairman of Mercury Insurance.

But Kathy Fairbanks of Californians for Fair Auto Insurance Rates contends that the statement of Rosenfield is misleading. She argued that the Continuous Coverage Auto Insurance Discount Act would permit drivers to maintain continuous coverage even if they change or decide to switch insurers. Although she admits that Mercury Insurance is indeed the sole financial contributor, she expects other businesses and consumer groups to financially support said move.

When asked to comment, Insurance Commissioner Steve Poizner said that although it is worth the effort to be skeptical of insurance company-backed initiatives, his department would have to finish analysis on the situation first before taking a stand. He continued that he might just inform the voters of the findings or he might “weigh in or not” his opinion in the hotly contested debate.

In the end, the final say would rely on the residents of California. Their votes would finally decide on the merit of said proposed law.

Big Insurance Company Wants To Rewrite Law They’ve Been Breaking

February 9th, 2010

By Robert Cruickshank, CALIFORNIA PROGRESS REPORT

There may be no better illustration of how corrupt our politics have become than the efforts of the Mercury Insurance Group to change a landmark consumer protection law that they are apparently violating on a regular basis. In 1988, California voters passed Proposition 103, a sweeping reform of the state’s auto insurance industry. 22 years later, as insurance companies have become one of the nation’s most reviled villains thanks to the murderous practices of health insurers, Mercury has put Proposition 17 on the ballot, which would raise auto insurance rates for many Californians.

Several years ago Mercury Insurance wanted to raise rates on customers who had a lapse in their insurance coverage. In 2005 California courts prevented this from happening. In Nevada, rates increased by 73% on customers with even a day’s lapse in coverage. Mercury wants to do this here in California, and authored Prop 17 to change Prop 103 to allow it.

But as the San Francisco Chronicle reports, Mercury may have been violating other parts of Prop 103 all along:

A high-profile California insurance company that is backing a controversial insurance measure on the June ballot has engaged in practices that may be illegal, including deceptive pricing and discrimination against consumers such as active members of the military and drivers of emergency vehicles, according to a state report obtained by The Chronicle.

The report, obtained through the state Public Records Act, alleges that Mercury Insurance Group may have violated Proposition 103, the landmark consumer protection law approved by voters in 1988. The measure limited the cost of policies and made civil rights and antitrust laws apply to the insurance industry.

The report referenced in the article shows that Mercury is the embodiment of the “evil insurance company” trope that has been so widely discussed in recent years. They’re charging higher rates in violation of the law until they get caught and slapped on the wrist by Steve Poizner, the state’s Insurance Commissioner and wannabe governor.

And what does Mercury do with those ill-gotten gains? Turn around and spend it on getting Prop 17 on the ballot and approved in order to legalize some of their most odious and destructive practices.

Mercury and Prop 17 are just one way in which the June election will be a battle over corporate power. Prop 16 is another effort by a large corporation, PG&E, to change laws and undo democratic rights that have obstructed their pursuit of limitless profits. And Prop 15 offers a chance to fight back by creating a publicly funded election for the Secretary of State races in 2014 and 2018 as a proof of concept to show that clean money can work in California – and that it is desperately needed.

Learn more about Mercury Insurance and Prop 17 at: StopProp17.org.
———–
Robert Cruickshank is a historian, activist, and teacher living in Monterey. He is a contributing editor at Calitics.com and works for the Courage Campaign, in addition to teaching political science at Monterey Peninsula College. Currently he is completing his Ph.D. dissertation in US history, on progressive politics in San Francisco in the 1960s and 1970s.

State Investigators Find All Sorts Of Dirty Tricks At Mercury Insurance

February 9th, 2010

By Chris Walters, THE CONSUMERIST

This summer Californians will be able to vote on Proposition 17, which if passed will allow insurers to bypass some legal restrictions on how much they can charge for auto insurance. Mercury Insurance Group is a big proponent of the proposition, but maybe that’s because it’s been possibly sidestepping the law in recent years anyway. Hey, making it legal will just prevent another state report like the one Carla Marinucci at the San Francisco Chronicle obtained, which contains findings that Mercury “has engaged in practices that may be illegal, including deceptive pricing and discrimination against consumers such as active members of the military and drivers of emergency vehicles.”

Here are just a few of the findings in the report, according to the paper:

“In its reporting, the state found evidence that Mercury may have violated state laws by:

– Flagging some consumers for higher rates if they had been in an accident, even if it was not their fault.

– Not immediately granting coverage to applicants including military personnel on active duty, “artists,” those employed “in the entertainment industry as actors, dancers, etc.,” and emergency vehicle drivers.

– Raising insurance premiums after its sales agents quoted prices for discounts for which the consumer was not eligible. The department said this was the single largest category of complaints it received about the firm.

– Collecting higher premiums than allowed by law by requiring its brokers to return part of their fees to the company.

– Requesting information about customers’ “national origin,” a practice that the department said “could raise questions about the legality of Mercury’s personal automobile policy cancellation and non-renewal decisions” under state law. Mercury agreed to block such data after the state investigators raised concerns.

State officials said the report uncovered 25 issues or questionable practices by Mercury, seven of which remain unresolved.”

“Insurer may have violated law, report reveals” – SFGate.com

Backer of Auto-Insurance Measure Has Ugly Record

February 8th, 2010

By Robert Gammon, EASTBAYEXPRESS.COM

Mercury Insurance Company, the sponsor of a June ballot measure that would allow auto insurers to charge higher rates to low-income drivers, appears to have engaged in numerous illegal and discriminatory practices over the years, according to a report by the state Department of Insurance obtained by the Chron. It’s not clear whether Mercury will face any penalties from its actions, but consumer advocate Harvey Rosenfield told the newspaper that if voters approve Proposition 17, it will allow the insurance company to “legalize the kind of discriminatory surcharges that they were caught doing by investigators.”

The state investigation, which ran from the mid 1990s to 2004, revealed that Mercury apparently discriminated against people who had been in accidents caused by others, military personnel, artists, actors, dancers, and emergency vehicle drivers in violation of state law. The company, which has a long history of using campaign funds to coerce politicians into doing what it wants, also duped new customers by quoting discounts that it never provided and requested that its customers reveal their “national origin.”

Prop. 17 would overturn existing consumer protections and would allow Mercury and other insurers to charge higher rates to people who have allowed their auto insurance to lapse. The company is advertising the proposition as a way to give discounts to drivers who have maintained their insurance, but consumer experts agree that the measure would adversely impact low-income motorists, who let their insurance lapse because they lost their jobs or got in financial trouble. Attorney General Jerry Brown also greatly helped Mercury by not mentioning this fact in the official ballot summary for the June Election.

Initiative Would Strip Attorney General & Legislature of Power to Write Ballot Title & Summary

February 5th, 2010

By Editor, CALIFORNIA’S CAPITOL BLOG

An initiative awaiting an official title and summary from Attorney General Jerry Brown would transfer the job of creating ballot descriptions to the Legislative Analyst.

The 21st Century Ballot Reform Act”would also forbid the Legislature from writing ballot titles and summaries as well.

Brown – and the Democratic majority Legislature — has been criticized for slanting the title and summary of several ballot measures.

Consumer Watchdog claimed Brown, a likely Democratic candidate for governor, rewrote the title and summary of Proposition 17 on the June ballot to benefit Mercury Insurance which contributed $13,000 to Brown and $3.5 million to place the measure on the ballot.

The proposition would allow insurers to use driving history as a factor in calculating insurance rates, something banned by Proposition 103, a 1988 ballot measure backed by the founder of Consumer Watchdog.

The first title said the measure “allows insurance companies to increase or decrease the cost of auto insurance based on a driver’s coverage history.”  The second title, which came after backers of the initiative amended it reads:

    “Allows auto insurance companies to base their prices in part on a driver’s history of insurance coverage.”

The second version will appear on the ballot.

“This title and summary differs from an earlier one because the substantive text of the two initiatives are different. It has nothing to do with politics,” wrote Jim Humes, Chief Deputy Attorney General, in response to Consumer Watchdog’s claims.

Sen. George Runner, a Lancaster Republican, filed a lawsuit over Brown’s title and summary of an initiative he backs requiring voters to present photo identification.

Brown was also sued by backers of Proposition 8, which bans same sex marriage. They claimed his title and summary was argumentative and prejudicial. A court tossed out the complaint.

On February 3, Brown wrote a title and summary for a measure that would prohibit implementation of AB 32, the landmark greenhouse gas reduction measure until state unemployment falls below 5.5 percent for four one year.

“Suspends air pollution control laws requiring major polluters to report and reduce greenhouse gas emissions that cause global warming until unemployment drops below specified level for full year.”

The description goes on to say that, if approved, the state would “abandon implementation of comprehensive greenhouse-gas-reduction program that includes increased renewable energy and cleaner fuel requirements, and mandatory emission reporting and fee requirements for major polluters such as power plants and oil refineries, until suspension is lifted.”

One of the measure’s backers, Assemblyman Dan Logue, Chico Republican, told Capitol Weekly’s Anthony York “this looks like (Brown) handed this over to the environmental community and asked them to write this summary for them.”

In another recent title and summary of a major overhaul of the state’s budget system that includes two-year budgeting a reduction in the vote requirement from two-thirds to a simple majority Brown said in the title, which is written in bold uppercase letters, that the measure “changes state budget process in several ways.”

The Legislature also has been criticized for writing the title and summary of some measures it passes.

For example, Proposition 15 on the June ballot, a measure by Sen. Loni Hancock, an Oakland Democrat, imposes a fee on lobbyists and their employers to create a fund for public financing of candidates running for Secretary of State.

Toward the end of the measure, the bill orders the Secretary of State to use this title and summary of the proposition.

“CALIFORNIA FAIR ELECTIONS ACT. This act creates a voluntary system for candidates for Secretary of State to qualify for a public campaign grant if they agree to strict spending limits and take no private contributions. Candidates would have to qualify before receiving the grant. Candidates who demonstrate sufficient public support would receive the same amount. Participating candidates would be prohibited from raising or spending money beyond the grant. There would be strict enforcement and accountability with published reports open to the public. Funded by voluntary contributions and by a $350 annual registration fee on lobbyists, lobbying firms, and lobbyist employers.”

The initiative that would turn the task of title and summary over to the Legislative Analyst would also bolster the state’s online ballot pamphlet by adding links to the most recent campaign finance reports, websites of supporters and opponents of a ballot measure and video or audio presentations requested by the authors of the ballot arguments for and against the measure.

Received by Brown’s office January 19, it has yet to receive a title and summary.